Grading rubric: reading the weight-management trial comparison
Version 1.1.0 · worksheet pinned to Flagship Weight Management 1.4.0 · AI-assisted source verification; human review none recorded. Total 20 points (five criteria, 0 to 4 each).
| Criterion (worksheet items) | 4 points | 3 points | 2 points | 1 points | 0 points |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Names the study design and what it allows Items 1, 3, 6 | Correctly separates the head-to-head trial, the separate placebo-controlled trials and the observational cohort, and states what each design allows and does not. | Separates the designs correctly; the reason for one of them is incomplete. | Separates the head-to-head trial from the rest but treats the placebo-controlled trials and the cohort alike. | Names a design but draws a comparison the design does not allow. | No design named, or the cross-trial subtraction is accepted. |
| Reads population, comparator, endpoint, time point and uncertainty Items 2, 5 | Reports all five from the record with correct numbers, and states what the interval does not tell you. | All five reported correctly; the interval's limits are partly stated. | Most reported correctly; one is missing or wrong. | Headline percentage only, or the interval is read as the range of individual results. | Numbers are wrong or not taken from the record. |
| Explains the estimand and how treatment discontinuation was handled Items 4, 8 | Explains what question each estimand answers, states how SURMOUNT-5 and the retatrutide trial handled stopping the drug, and says study completion is not treatment discontinuation. | Explains both trials' handling correctly; the completion-versus-discontinuation point is missing. | Explains one trial's handling correctly. | Repeats the words without explaining the question each answers. | Missing or incorrect. |
| Says what a result supports and no more Items 9 | Writes a statement limited to the trial, population, time point and design, and picks the verdict Overstated for the classmate's claim with a correct reason. | A supported statement with one overreach, or the right verdict with a partial reason. | A supported statement but the wrong verdict, or the right verdict with no reason. | Restates the headline as a general fact about the drugs. | Missing. |
| Reopens the exact result from a copied citation Items 7 | Copies the citation, reopens the versioned address in a clean window, reports the version and checksum, and finds the pointer from the 1.0.0 record to the update. | Reopens the exact result and reports the version; misses the checksum or the pointer to the update. | Reopens the result but cannot say which version it is. | Opens the page, not the versioned record. | Cannot reopen the result. |
Score what the student wrote against the record, not against the instructor key’s wording. Several correct phrasings exist. The key lists the facts a strong answer contains.