Grading rubric: reading the weight-management trial comparison

Version 1.1.0 · worksheet pinned to Flagship Weight Management 1.4.0 · AI-assisted source verification; human review none recorded. Total 20 points (five criteria, 0 to 4 each).

Rubric: criteria in rows, levels worth 4 to 0 points in columns
Criterion (worksheet items)4 points3 points2 points1 points0 points
Names the study design and what it allows
Items 1, 3, 6
Correctly separates the head-to-head trial, the separate placebo-controlled trials and the observational cohort, and states what each design allows and does not.Separates the designs correctly; the reason for one of them is incomplete.Separates the head-to-head trial from the rest but treats the placebo-controlled trials and the cohort alike.Names a design but draws a comparison the design does not allow.No design named, or the cross-trial subtraction is accepted.
Reads population, comparator, endpoint, time point and uncertainty
Items 2, 5
Reports all five from the record with correct numbers, and states what the interval does not tell you.All five reported correctly; the interval's limits are partly stated.Most reported correctly; one is missing or wrong.Headline percentage only, or the interval is read as the range of individual results.Numbers are wrong or not taken from the record.
Explains the estimand and how treatment discontinuation was handled
Items 4, 8
Explains what question each estimand answers, states how SURMOUNT-5 and the retatrutide trial handled stopping the drug, and says study completion is not treatment discontinuation.Explains both trials' handling correctly; the completion-versus-discontinuation point is missing.Explains one trial's handling correctly.Repeats the words without explaining the question each answers.Missing or incorrect.
Says what a result supports and no more
Items 9
Writes a statement limited to the trial, population, time point and design, and picks the verdict Overstated for the classmate's claim with a correct reason.A supported statement with one overreach, or the right verdict with a partial reason.A supported statement but the wrong verdict, or the right verdict with no reason.Restates the headline as a general fact about the drugs.Missing.
Reopens the exact result from a copied citation
Items 7
Copies the citation, reopens the versioned address in a clean window, reports the version and checksum, and finds the pointer from the 1.0.0 record to the update.Reopens the exact result and reports the version; misses the checksum or the pointer to the update.Reopens the result but cannot say which version it is.Opens the page, not the versioned record.Cannot reopen the result.

Score what the student wrote against the record, not against the instructor key’s wording. Several correct phrasings exist. The key lists the facts a strong answer contains.

Instructor key · Faculty guide · Teaching hub