Faculty guide: reading the weight-management trial comparison

Version 1.1.0 (2026-11-14) · Flagship Weight Management 1.4.0 · AI-assisted source verification; human review none recorded. Not yet run. Human review and the pilot are pending until real participants complete the tasks and a named person records the results.

Goal. Students learn to tell a head-to-head trial from a cross-trial comparison, to say what a result supports and what it does not, and to reopen the exact result from a copied citation.

Time. About 65 minutes (50 minutes if items 8 and 9 are set as homework). Needs a browser and a printed or on-screen worksheet.

Before class

  • Open the worksheet and the instructor key. The key is a public, unlisted page: share it with instructors, not in the student link.
  • Confirm the release: every source link names Flagship Weight Management 1.4.0. If a newer release has shipped, these links still return the version students were given.
  • Skim the five results on the comparison page so you know which one is the only head-to-head trial (SURMOUNT-5).

Class flow

  1. 5 min. Frame the task: a classmate quotes a bigger percentage from a different trial. Can it be compared?
  2. 20 min. Students work items 1 to 3 in pairs using the comparison page and the Verify this result panel. Debrief: design first, numbers second.
  3. 20 min. Items 4, 5 and 8: estimands, intervals and treatment discontinuation. Use the key's wording for the debrief.
  4. 15 min. Items 6 and 7: the observational cohort, then copy a citation and reopen it in a private window; open the 1.0.0 address and find the pointer to the update.
  5. 10 min. Item 9: write a supported statement, give the claim a verdict, then open the claim check and compare.

Common misreadings to listen for

  • Treating a bigger percentage in one trial as proof against a different trial (the central error of the lesson).
  • Reading a confidence interval as the range in which most patients fall.
  • Reading study completion as treatment adherence.
  • Assuming a registry result and the paper report the same analysis (SURMOUNT-1 shows they can differ).

These are anticipated before any pilot. They are not observations. The pilot sheet records what actually happens.

Where each comparison row was checked (release 1.4.0)

ResultChecked againstMatched / disclosed differencesNot read
SURMOUNT-5 (phase 3b, open-label)ClinicalTrials.gov results; PubMed abstract; Statistical analysis plan4 / 0Publisher page
STEP 1 (double-blind)PubMed abstract; ClinicalTrials.gov results; Statistical analysis plan3 / 1Publisher page
SURMOUNT-1 (phase 3, double-blind)PubMed abstract; ClinicalTrials.gov results; Statistical analysis plan; Study protocol3 / 1Publisher page
Retatrutide phase 2 (double-blind)PubMed abstract; ClinicalTrials.gov results; Statistical analysis plan5 / 0Publisher page
Rodriguez and colleagues, JAMA Internal Medicine 2024: cohort study, not a randomized trialOpen-access full text9 / 0Publisher page
  • The four journal papers behind the trial rows could not be opened by WPF's automated access (HTTP 403), so the exact table or figure for those numbers is not located; students check the registry results page and the analysis plan instead. The observational cohort was checked against its open-access full text.
  • The lesson teaches how to read evidence. It is not medical advice and recommends no treatment.

Materials

Teaching hub